Hunting Matthew Nichols is a slow, but thoughtful mockumentary that builds tension the right way
Synopsis
Two decades after her brother mysteriously disappeared, a determined woman sets out to solve the case, and when a disturbing piece of evidence is revealed, she starts to believe that he may still be alive.
Hunting Matthew Nichols Good Points
Immersive
It definitely fully commits to the format, with the interviews, pacing, and structure feeling authentic, which draws you in.
Performances
They especially are good in the interview segments, and they really sell the illusion that this could be a real case, which is exactly what you need and want from this kind of film.
Strong Emotional Core
Beyond the mystery, we also have themes of grief, obsession, and unresolved relationships which add some extra layers.
Tension
The film does take its time building unease and dread, where it doesn’t rush anything, but it lets the discomfort grow, and this is pretty well handled overall.
Subtle Unease
There’s a constant undercurrent of something being off, and I do like it when films have that feeling without having to display much action on screen to show it.
Pacing
The gradual reveal of details mirrors real documentaries you would watch on Netflix etc, and everything feels natural and well done in that regard.
Clever Meta Commentary
It has some light nods to The Blair Witch Project add some self-awareness without becoming annoying.
Standout Animated Sequence
I won’t spoil much about this scene, but I loved it.
Polished Low-Budget Execution
The film looks clean and is well-constructed.
Hunting Matthew Nichols Bad Points
Final Act
The shift into heavier horror at the end did feel a bit rushed for my tastes, and a bit off kilt, where it compressed ideas that probably needed more time to breathe.
Limited Scares
Despite strong tension, the film doesn’t deliver many memorable or impactful scares, which might bother some – for me the atmosphere carried it – but I suspect a a lot of people will want more.
Familiar Found-Footage Issues
Classic genre problems creep in such as logical gaps, convenience-driven filming, and moments that require suspension of disbelief.
Slight Repetition Early On
The documentary format does sometime revisit some similar beats before moving on.
Transition
The transition from documentary to the supernatural elements isn’t as smooth as it could be.
Final Thoughts on Hunting Matthew Nichols
Hunting Matthew Nichols is a slow, but thoughtful mockumentary that builds tension the right way, even if the ending left me a little disappointed, but I still enjoyed it overall, and definitely a cut above most recent found-footage horror.
Hunting Matthew Nichols Trailer
Hunting Matthew Nichols on IMDB
Watch Hunting Matthew Nichols
Leave a Reply