The Creep Tapes Season 2 Review

The Creep Tapes Season 2 (2025) Review

You know what you are getting with Creep, and if you love it, you love it, and boy do I love it.

Synopsis

The Creep Tapes Season 2 is a six-episode anthology series that delves deeper into the world of the serial killer, “Peachfuzz,” from the Creep films, as featured in a collection of his found-footage tapes.

Co-written by creators Mark Duplass and Patrick Brice, with Duplass starring, the season features a new victim in each episode who is lured into the killer’s increasingly unsettling games under false pretenses.

My Thoughts on The Creep Tapes Season 2

Good Points

Expands the Universe

Season two of The Creep Tapes builds on the original series while introducing some new scenarios and ideas, and the tapes show Peachfuzz’s crimes in some inventive fresh ways.

Psychological Tension

Creep has always excelled at slow building dread, and season 2 is no different, and you feel the fear and tension without even much happening.

Character Depth

Hints at Peachfuzz’s motivations and backstory are carefully placed in season 2, as it explores his darkness without overexplaining anything.

Dark Humor Balance

You have to love the dark humor at play.

Strong Lead Performance

Mark Duplass, as always, delivers a standout portrayal of Peachfuzz, with his usual charm, menace, and unpredictability.

Bold Storytelling

Season two experiments more with some new formats and story types, which kind of gives the franchise a little sense of evolution.

Guest Performances

David Dastmalchian, Robert Longstreet, and Diego Josef are all pretty solid when they are on screen.

Inventive Scenarios

Each episode presents a new, creative setup, ranging from twisted home videos to a house flipping pilot gone wrong.

Production Value

The cinematography, lighting, and editing continue to support the tense, found footage aesthetic at play.

Episode Pacing

Each episode builds everything carefully, as you would expect, and you become quite absorbed in it all.

Bad Points

Risk of Repetition

Despite new scenarios, some plot beats do echo Season 1’s format closely, which is fine in one way, but you don’t want it to become overkill.

A very minor ‘bad’ point though.

Inconsistent Tone Moments

The balance of dark humor and horror occasionally tips a bit too far toward comedy

Final Thoughts on The Creep Tapes Season 2

As you can tell from the above, I really enjoyed Season two of The Creep Tapes, and it proves a ‘sequel’ can expand a universe without losing anything.

You know what you are getting with Creep, and if you love it, you love it, and boy do I love it.

Now to wait for season 3!

The Creep Tapes Season 2 Trailer
The Creep Tapes Season 2 on IMDB
Watch The Creep Tapes Season 2
Creep Review
Creep 2 Review
Creep Season 1 Review

Let Me Know Your Thoughts!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Hello fellow found footage nerds.

I watch a lot of found footage horror movies, so decided to do a simple page with all the reviews of the ones I watch, and hopefully make this site an index of hundreds of reviews.

Found Footage Horror Movies
Found Footage Horror Movies
@foundfootagehorrormovies.com@foundfootagehorrormovies.com

Found Footage Horror Movie Reviews.

165 posts
0 followers

Latest Found Footage Horror Trailers

Invoking Scream (2026)
Primal Darkness (2026)
The Man With The Black Umbrella (2025)
Killer Rental (2025)
Let’s See Playback (2025)
Destroy This Tape (2025)
Sleep Stalker (2025)
The Stickman’s Hollow (2025)
House on Eden (2025)
Strange Harvest (2025)
Don’t Log Off (2025)

Join the found footage club

Stay updated with my latest posts.

Found Footage Horror Movies
Found Footage Horror Movies
@foundfootagehorrormovies.com@foundfootagehorrormovies.com

Found Footage Horror Movie Reviews.

165 posts
0 followers

JOIN ME ON SOCIAL MEDIA

Instagram

Threads

Facebook