Tinsman Road is slow, imperfect, and niche, and a hard film to blindly recommend.
Synopsis
In the backwoods of New Jersey, a young man navigates the serpentine mystery surrounding his long-missing sister and their family home.
My Thoughts on Tinsman Road
Good Points
Genuine Emotion
The emotional honesty in Tinsman Road really shows, and the chemistry between Robbie and Leslie is the heartbeat of the film.
Purposeful Found Footage
The found footage style actually feels essential rather than gimmicky here, where the camera exists for a reason.
Natural Performances
Leslie Banfitch delivers a quietly devastating performance, and Robbie plays her son with a lot of emotion, letting the silence and hesitation do most of the work.
Faith and Grief
The movie treats faith as survival, and all the conversations about angels and signs from beyond feel very personal, and never preachy.
Atmosphere Over Effects
All the tension comes from all of the quiet stillness, which can be a good and bad thing.
Emotional Intimacy
It kinda feels like the director Robbie Banfitch is exposing his own scars.
Symbolism
A lot of the imagery in the film represent the cycle of searching and remembering, where each symbol adds emotional depth without over explanation.
Good Third Act
I personally liked the final act, but I think a lot of people won’t find it enough.
Bad Points
Slow Pacing/Runtime
The film moves at a deliberate crawl, as it’s a 2 hour film that could have easily been cut.
Minimal Horror
For a horror-labeled film, actual scare attempts are minimal, and it’s more about the mood, which might disappoint some.
Repetitive Visuals
The lack of visual variation in the film dulls some of impact the longer the film goes on.
Dialogue Repetition
Many conversations circle the same themes without much new insight.
Lack of Escalation
As said above, the tension comes from the stillness of it all, and there’s little sense of progression toward something bigger or more dangerous.
Depends what you like in that aspect!
Emotional Overload
The film is relentlessly heavy, and at times, its sadness can feel a bit suffocating by the end.
Final Thoughts on Tinsman Road
Tinsman Road is a deeply personal and quietly unsettling film about grief, but it will have a very niche appeal.
I am sure a lot of people will find it dull and boring and zone out by the half way point, and I totally get that 100%.
It would have helped if it wasn’t 2 hours long, as it doesn’t earn that right at all, but I liked the emotional honesty the film shows.
It’s slow, imperfect, and niche, and a hard film to blindly recommend – but it’s also moving, sincere, and beautifully human.
Found Footage Horror Movies 
Let Me Know Your Thoughts!